Pay No More Attention to G3

First, it was the Anglican Catholic Church's refusal to censure Robert Hart for his online behavior and his embrace of his little brother David Bentley Hart's heretical "certain universalism".  Then it was the Anglican Province of America's tolerance of clergy in their midst, such as Wesley Walker the Woke, who promulgated said heresy.  Now this:

From the Anglican Catholic Church (ACC) on anglicancatholic.org

A Statement on Calvin Robinson

At approximately 3:00 pm today (1/29) members of the College of Bishops of the ACC were made aware of a post made on X showing the end of a speech made by Calvin Robinson at the National Pro-Life Summit in Washington, DC. In it, he closed his comments with a gesture that many have interpreted as a pro-Nazi salute.

While we cannot say what was in Mr. Robinson’s heart when he did this, his action appears to have been an attempt to curry favor with certain elements of the American political right by provoking its opposition. Mr. Robinson had been warned that online trolling and other such actions (whether in service of the left or right) are incompatible with a priestly vocation and was told to desist. Clearly, he has not, and as such, his license in this Church has been revoked. He is no longer serving as a priest in the ACC.

Furthermore, we understand that this is not just an administrative matter. The Holocaust was an episode of unspeakable horror, enacted by a regime of evil men. We condemn Nazi ideology and anti-Semitism in all its forms. And we believe that those who mimic the Nazi salute, even as a joke or an attempt to troll their opponents, trivialize the horror of the Holocaust and diminish the sacrifice of those who fought against its perpetrators. Such actions are harmful, divisive, and contrary to the tenets of Christian charity.

Finally, we pray that God will give us grace to lay aside our unhappy divisions, and we commend our nation and ourselves to his Almighty protection.

Fr. Robinson replies:

For the record, in case it needs saying: I am not a Nazi.

I gave a talk at a pro-life event that seemed to go down well, I am pleased to have contributed to what I believe to be the most important of causes. The enemy hates that, of course, and the attacks have been plentiful. That is fine and to be expected.

The joke at the end was a mockery of the hysterical “liberals” who called Elon Musk a Nazi for quite clearly showing the audience his heart was with them. Context is key, but sometimes people ignore context to confirm their own prejudices. People see what they want to see.

My attempt at dry wit, in that typical British way, was not a joke at the expense of WWII, nor an admission of my membership in the Nationalist Socialist Party. That would be an incredibly ignorant and bad faith assumption to make. The responses are very telling, though. The people who understand, cheer - those who have eyes to see. The people who do not want to understand, reach for their pitchforks. They have found a new channel for their hated. They remain in my prayers; may the Lord soften their hearts.

Do not let the liberals distract from the real issue, the matter at hand, that we are allowing and enabling infanticide, and it must stop.

Whether a silly old cleric like me makes a poor joke is irrelevant. Do not be swayed and distracted by the enemy whispering in your ears. Focus on the light.

All human life is sacred. Imago Dei.

I will take the consequences as they come. Those of us in the pro-life camp adorn the full armour of God.

You can consider my joke crass. But I ask you to consider if your responses have been proportionate?

I'm reminded of Robert Conquest's Second Law, paraphrased here by John Derbyshire, and it now seems that it is applicable to G3:

"Any organization not explicitly and constitutionally right-wing will sooner or later become left-wing."

We saw it in Protestantism, we saw it in the Anglican Communion, and now we're seeing in certain quarters of the Anglican Continuum as they drift toward Liberal Catholicism and who knows what else in 100 years.  Robert Hart rejoices.  Just think about that for a moment. As a fellow priest remarks tonight, "If Robert Hart remains untouched, then this is a witch hunt."

I used to wish that the Orthodox Anglican Church, where I am canonically resident, would join G3, but now I am thankful that we haven't. G3's tolerance of DBH's certain universalism should have been the first clue.

I can speak with virtual certainty that there will be many faithul in G3 who will be profoundly upset about the ACC's stupid move here.  It'll be interesting to see how that eventually shakes out.